HOME / / Co-living / How to Tell If a Coliving Company Is Legit (NYC Checklist)

How to Tell If a Coliving Company Is Legit (NYC Checklist)

How to Tell If a Coliving Company Is Legit (NYC Checklist)

November 19, 2026 | By Roomrs

The listing looked perfect. Sunny photos, a fair price, a friendly landlord who was “out of the country right now, but can send the keys.” You sent a deposit to hold the room. You were already picking a spot for the plant. Then the messages stopped.

It happens more than anyone likes to admit, and it happens most to people who are new in town and in a hurry. If you are moving to New York from another city, or another country, you are exactly who scammers are looking for. You cannot see the apartment, you do not know the neighborhoods yet, and you have a move-in date you cannot miss.

The good news: spotting a fake takes less than you think. A real company and a fake one behave very differently once you start asking questions. Here is a simple checklist you can use on any company, including us.

Why coliving is a magnet for scams (and for good companies)

Coliving is built for people who need a place fast, often from far away, often on short notice. That is the same profile scammers target. It also means a good coliving company has to earn your trust before you ever visit, which is why the best ones make everything easy to check.

So treat the next 15 minutes as part of the move. Go through the points below before you pay anyone anything.

The 10-point checklist

1. Read the reviews, including the bad ones

Check Google and Trustpilot, and look at more than the star rating. Every real company has some unhappy customers. What you are looking for is detail and a response. Are the complaints specific (“the heating broke in January and it took a week”) or vague? Does the company reply, politely and with facts?

A company with only perfect reviews, all posted in the same week, is just as suspicious as one with none.

2. Ask to see the lease before you pay

A legitimate company will happily show you the lease and the house rules before you pay a deposit or any rent. (A small application fee that is refunded if you are not approved is normal.) If someone pushes you to pay first and “sort out the paperwork later,” walk away. The lease is the single most important document in the whole process, and you have every right to read it.

3. Be wary of unusual ways to pay

Wire transfers, gift cards, cash in an envelope, a payment app to a personal account: these are the classic signs. Money sent that way is almost impossible to get back. A real company has a proper payment system with a receipt. At Roomrs, you pay through our online system with most major cards or by US bank transfer.

4. Check that the company is real

It should have a working website, a physical address, a phone number and a support team you can actually reach. Search the company name together with the word “reviews” and see what comes up. In New York you can also look up a business by name in the New York Department of State’s public corporation search, which takes about two minutes.

5. Check the address

Put the address into Google Maps and open Street View. Does the building look like the photos? Then run the listing photos through a reverse image search (in Google Lens, for example). If the same pictures show up on a different listing in another city, you have your answer.

A fully equipped kitchen in a Roomrs apartment

6. See the room, even if you cannot go in person

Look for plenty of photos, video, and ideally a virtual tour or a live video walk-through. We do not do in-person tours at Roomrs, so every listing comes with photos, video and a virtual tour, and our team can walk you through any room. A listing with three blurry photos and no way to see more is a warning sign.

7. Make sure the fees are clear

A real company can tell you exactly what you pay and when. At Roomrs, you pay a service fee when you apply (refunded if we cannot approve you), your first month’s rent, and a deposit equal to one month’s rent, which we return after you move out as long as the space is in good shape. If anyone is vague about the money, ask again. Vague answers about fees are a warning sign on their own. For the full picture, see what Roomrs costs and what is included.

8. Watch out for “too good to be true”

A price far below the neighborhood average, pressure to decide today, or a landlord who is always “abroad” are classic scam signs. Real rooms in good locations get taken quickly, but a real company does not need you to panic.

9. Notice how they communicate

Do they answer your questions, or dodge them? Do emails come from a company address or a free personal one? Are there typos in every message and odd, pushy phrasing? A real team answers clearly and does not mind slow, careful questions.

10. Keep records of everything

Save the listing, the messages, the lease and every receipt. If anything goes wrong, a paper trail is your best friend.

Red flags: walk away if you see these

  • You are asked to pay before you have seen a lease.
  • The payment method is a wire, gift cards, cash or a personal account.
  • The price is far below similar rooms nearby.
  • The landlord cannot meet, video call or show you anything real.
  • You are pressured to decide today.
  • The listing photos show up on other websites for other cities.
  • You are asked for a security deposit larger than one month’s rent. In New York, most residential rentals cap the deposit at one month’s rent.

Green flags: signs you are dealing with a real company

  • Clear, public pricing and a written lease you can read in advance.
  • A real, searchable history: reviews, press, a website that has been around.
  • A support team that replies to your questions the same day.
  • An online application and payment system with receipts.
  • No surprise fees, and a clear explanation of the ones that exist.

A 10-minute background check you can do tonight

If you only have a few minutes, do these four things in order:

  • Search the company name plus “reviews” and “scam”. Read the first page of results.
  • Look at the Google and Trustpilot ratings and read a handful of the most recent reviews.
  • Put the address into Street View and run the main photo through a reverse image search.
  • Ask for the lease and the full list of fees in writing, and see how fast and how clearly they answer.

If all four feel solid, you are probably fine. If any of them feels off, trust that feeling and ask more questions.

Is Roomrs legit? An honest answer

We would not be writing this checklist if we were afraid of it, so here is what you will find if you check us. Our reviews are mostly positive: 4.5 on Google and 4.5 on Trustpilot, from more than 490 reviews. Like any company with many residents, we also have some unhappy reviews, mainly about maintenance and communication, and you should read them. We do not offer in-person tours, so we make up for it with detailed photos, video and virtual tours. Check the lease, check the reviews on several sites, and ask us anything.

What if you already sent money?

Do not feel embarrassed. These scams are designed by professionals, and smart people fall for them. Act quickly:

  • Call your bank or card company right away and ask whether the payment can be stopped or disputed. The sooner you call, the better your chances.
  • Report it to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to the New York State Attorney General’s office.
  • Report the listing to the website where you found it, so others do not fall for the same one.
  • Keep every message, receipt and screenshot.

100,000+ nights stayed. Here is what residents say.

Rated 4.5 on Google and 4.5 on Trustpilot, from more than 490 reviews.

★★★★★ “Moving to nyc was a huge transition, and Roomrs honestly made the housing process much less stressful. As someone relocating from another country, having a straightforward leasing process and a responsive team gave me a lot of peace of mind before I even arrived.”

Stav N., Trustpilot, July 2026

★★★★★ “They made moving to NYC quick and easy. They were also very good at communicating which was helpful in finding my ideal apartment.”

Wyatt H., Trustpilot, December 2025

See all reviews on Google and Trustpilot.

Questions people ask

Is it safe to rent a room without visiting it first?

It can be, if the company makes everything verifiable: real photos and video, a virtual tour, a written lease, clear pricing and a way to talk to a real person. Never rent a place that cannot show you any of those.

Are virtual tours enough?

A good virtual tour plus photos and a video walk-through shows you the room, the common areas and the building. Combine that with reviews and a lease you can read, and you have far more to go on than most people get from a ten-minute visit.

Should I trust a company with a mix of good and bad reviews?

Usually, yes. A mix is what real businesses look like. Check whether the company responds to the bad ones.

If something feels off, trust that feeling and ask a question. A legitimate company will welcome it.

Ready to see real rooms with real prices?

Real photos, real prices and a full breakdown before you apply. See available rooms. Comparing options? Read Roomrs vs Outpost and how fast you can move into coliving in NYC.

Similar articles you might like